How to Make Paella at Home

March 6, 2018

Paella has always intimidated me. Between the ingredients and the way it’s prepared, I don’t think there is a dish more misunderstood and contentious than paella. But guys, it turns out, paella is incredibly easy to make. Surprise! Remember that paella workshop I attended a few months ago? That was where all of my presumptions about paella were wiped clean and I have Chef Paul Canales, of one of the Bay Area’s best Spanish restaurants Duende, to thank.

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

The key to Chef Canales’ Basque inspired paella is good quality rice and a well seasoned sofrito. He recommends Bomba rice, which absorbs three times its volume in broth (versus the normal two) and still remains firm yet chewy and plump. Any other Valencia rice could be substituted. And then there’s the sofrito – a base of garlic, onion, tomatoes, saffron and paprika, that serves as the foundation for any authentic paella. This was the game changer for me.

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

As far as the rest of the ingredients, we learned that traditional paella consists of beans, rabbit, and snails. After all, it was the peasants in the rice growing region of Valencia that used ingredients that were native to the wetlands. Seafood was, in fact, a much later addition. But the beautiful thing about paella is that you can truly put anything you want in it. It’s just then all about timing. Meats should always go in first and seafood at the very end. And always, fish before shellfish!

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

Paella has quickly become my favorite thing to make when entertaining. It’s easy, quick and always a crowd pleaser. Serve it with some pintxos, some jamón, Chef Canales’ delectable Ensalada de Col, plenty of Spanish wine, and you’ve got yourself a fiesta!

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

How to Make Paella at Home | HonestlyYUM (

Paella de Carne

Servings: 2 servings in a 30cm pan



  1. Preheat oven to 450 degrees. If using a convection over, preheat to 400.
  2. In a 30cm paella pan (recipe can be doubled in a larger pan), make a sofrito by heating the the olive oil over medium heat and adding onion and garlic.
  3. Season the onion and garlic with a generous pinch of salt and cook until translucent.
  4. Add tomatoes and cook until the tomatoes begin to dry out and form a residue.
  5. Add the saffron and pimeton, lower the heat and briefly stir to incorporate.
  6. Add the diced chicken meat and stir well over medium heat.
  7. Add the bomba rice and stir to coat thoroughly with the sofrito.
  8. Raise the heat to high and add the warm stock. Taste and adjust the seasoning by adding salt. As rice is not stirred during cooking, it's important that the seasoning be correct at the point. It should taste well seasoned but overly salty.
  9. When the paella reaches a boil, add the sprig of rosemary and butter beans and cook on the stove for 5 minutes.
  10. Place paella in preheated oven.
  11. After 5 minutes, add the shrimp.
  12. After 3 minutes, add the clams hinge side down. Do not overcrowd the clams so that you can give them room to open.
  13. Cook for an additional 5 minutes.
  14. If there is any additional liquid, place the plan over high heat on the stove to remove any additional liquid.
  15. Allow the paella to sit for 5-10 minutes before serving.


Specialty tools and ingredients used:

(images by HonestlyYUM)


Since we won’t have any decent, fresh, tomatoes until this summer, could a can of diced tomatoes be used instead or would there be a big difference in taste?

Yes, you can absolutely substitute canned diced tomatoes! I actually think we canned here 😉 The better quality, the better the taste!

So, just a 15 oz can for this recipe? We usually use Hunts…is there a better canned tomatoe that you would recommend?

The Arroz Caldoso my friend ordered was a Valencia-style rice with shrimps, chicken, calamari, red sofrito, and saffron.

Is it supposed to be black on the edges? I’m just wondering because it looks like it might be burnt. Does this offer something to the flavor of the rest of the dish?

I live in Spain and eat many paellas. The best bit of any paella are the toasted bits, particularly on the bottom. As the recipe says you don’t stir the paella and there is a tendency for it to stick to the bottom a little.

The paella pan is just metal, with no non-stick coating. You can therefore scrape away and get every last toasted bit.

Leave a Reply

Link Love